I am 5'10 and these socks fit me really well.. I have athletic legs too so my calfs are a bit wider then normal girls.. these hit me about 3 inches above my knee, a little lower then in the picture but I am tall so I expected that. I like wearing them with my mid-calf high boots and just letting them bunch around the top ,or pulled up, they look good either way... I like how soft they are and the elastic seems to hold well, although I have not worn them all day yet. The fabric does seem like it would stretch out a bit the longer you wear them. Overall they are really nice and for 24 dollars not that bad of a price for their quality.

"One size fits most"--ha! I am a size nine in shoes and 5'7"--hardly an abnormal body type--and these socks, supposedly size 9-11, barely come up past my knees. Not at all like the picture that shows them reaching thigh high. What's more, the elastic isn't strong enough to keep them from sliding down, either. So in all, I'm very disappointed in this purchase. Unless you're really short, I wouldn't recommend these, especially since they're non-returnable. What a waste of money.

I got these socks as a gift and they are wonderful! They're very warm and cute. My only complaint is that they don't stay up well at all on me. They fall so far down my legs that if I don't keep pulling them up, they end up pooling around my ankles. However, I have remedied this problem by wearing them with a garter belt. For reference, I'm about 5'6" and 120 lbs. If you need a pair of warm, adorable socks, look no further!